The BEST way to Evaluate your Team

assessment evaluation new manager performance management Mar 28, 2024
 

Traditional performance assessments take a lot of time and don’t always provide the value they promise.  If you are looking to get a snap-shot of how your team is doing, how your employees are doing relative to one another, and some guidance to help support and develop them, then let’s talk about the 9-box assessment tool.

 

 

The 9-box assessment tool offers a comprehensive approach to evaluating team performance, designed to provide managers with a nuanced understanding of their employees' current performance levels and future potential. Unlike traditional performance evaluations, which are often conducted infrequently and may lack depth, the nine-box method encourages regular touch-points with team members to address barriers, celebrate achievements, and encourage professional growth. By incorporating both performance and potential into its framework, this tool enables managers to compare employees across different roles and career stages, facilitating fair and equitable assessments.

 

The assessment process involves plotting employees on a grid with performance represented on the horizontal axis and potential on the vertical axis. Performance considerations include factors such as meeting deadlines, achieving objectives, and collaboration skills, while potential encompasses future growth opportunities and alignment with organizational goals. By categorizing employees into nine distinct boxes based on their performance and potential ratings, managers gain valuable insights into the strengths and development areas of each team member.

 

The bottom left box represents under-performers with low potential, signalling a need for support and intervention to address performance issues or explore alternative roles within the organization. Moving up the grid, employees in the middle categories may exhibit inconsistent performance or moderate effectiveness, indicating opportunities for targeted development plans and performance improvement initiatives.

 

Conversely, employees in the top-right box are identified as high performers with high potential, positioning them as key contributors to the team's success and potential future leaders within the organization. These individuals require strategic investment and recognition to retain their talent and maximize their impact. Similarly, employees in other high-potential categories merit focused development efforts to nurture their growth and capitalize on their talents.

 

Furthermore, the assessment tool encourages managers to allocate resources effectively by prioritizing support and development efforts based on employees' placement within the grid. While under-performers may require minimal investment, high-potential individuals warrant significant attention and resources to foster their professional development and career advancement.

 

Ultimately, the nine-box assessment tool serves as a valuable guide for managers seeking to optimize team performance and cultivate a culture of continuous improvement and development. By leveraging this framework, managers can identify talent gaps, tailor development initiatives, and empower their team members to reach their full potential.

 

 

Looking for more? Download my FREE New Manager Checklist with 100 practical leadership tips and mindset changes to help you be an effective and inspiring leader for your team.

New Manager Guide